Back Home

Open Designs

Community. Driven.

General Talk: [Closed] Open Designs Competition Theme Vote

Bottom of Page

1 to 50 of 81

  1. <
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. >
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008 edited by perthmetro on the 24th April 2008 at 08:56:57 EDT
     
    OD Design Competition
    Theme Vote

    Check back here regularly to read the latest updates

    • To vote just cut and paste this thread and add your name under the theme you like - Add your own theme if you want.

    • You can vote for only two themes from the list

    • You may change your vote/s at anytime, just make sure you make a NEW post to reflect your change (DON'T JUST UPDATE YOUR OLD POST) - the final count will be the what the final post reads.

    • The vote will be at least one week and a max of two weeks from the date of this first post (April 22, 2008)


    Votes for
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination

    11. non-blog theme
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008 edited by Sean on the 23rd April 2008 at 01:37:59 EDT
     
    Lets have the vote be at least one week and a max of two weeks from the date of this first post (April 22, 2008) to allow for many to take part.
    •  
      CommentAuthorbradm81
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81bigsmile
    •  
      CommentAuthorkirby145
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008 edited by kirby145 on the 23rd April 2008 at 02:13:09 EDT
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81
    ------
    I kind of want to vote for 2, the second being non-blog theme. But that's too broad to pick on it's own.
  5.  
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81
    • CommentAuthorbluecafe
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81
    •  
      CommentAuthorjanpd24
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    (Ok to vote for more than one? If not, let me know and I'll edit!)

    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
  8.  
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    •  
      CommentAuthorNickyD
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    Side note, we need someone who can count up the total votes once we close voting in a week or two, so if someone wants to start that now in a document off site and when the time comes, post the final total, that would be awesome.
    •  
      CommentAuthorJeremyD
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    • CommentAuthorNOWdesign
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    • CommentAuthorNOWdesign
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    I voted the OD Garden as I think it's about time the skills of the coders where combined with their design abilities, rather than just the design abilities on their own, as some of the coding on the templates I have seen here can be pretty bad!

    I don't really see the point in numbers 2 to 12 as they are all pretty standard and stuff that would be too easy to copy from elsewhere.

    It's about time we where tested!
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    @Sean... I'll count them... all we have to do is count them at the end as the tally is updated each time someone copies the thread.

    I take it it's ok to vote more than once? Shall we limit it?
  15.  
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell
    • CommentAuthorwfiedler
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD
    wfiedler

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell

    14. Retro design
    •  
      CommentAuthoricyone
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    Icyone
    •  
      CommentAuthoricyone
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    Unless people were following the old thread the voting system is very confusing
    •  
      CommentAuthorkirby145
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD
    wfiedler

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell
    icyone

    14. Retro design
    ------
    icyone i update it for you, you just put your name under it after copy and pasting most recent vote.
    •  
      CommentAuthorbradm81
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    Maybe Pete and the other mods can keep the first post updated.
    •  
      CommentAuthorbakercad
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    Posted By: bradm81Maybe Pete and the other mods can keep the first post updated.


    thumbup
    •  
      CommentAuthoricyone
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    thanks kirby145 bigsmile
    •  
      CommentAuthorDENiAL
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD
    wfiedler

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell
    icyone
    DENiAL
    14. Retro design
    • CommentAuthorUrgenus
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD
    wfiedler

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell
    icyone
    DENiAL
    Urgenus

    14. Retro design
    •  
      CommentAuthoryugnats
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD
    wfiedler

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme
    bradm81

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell
    icyone
    DENiAL
    Urgenus
    yugnats

    14. Retro design
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008 edited by Sean on the 23rd April 2008 at 14:15:17 EDT
     
    Just an FYI, so everyone here can see who the current admins and moderators are, look at our board page.

    Also, I think people should only have one vote, meaning you can only vote once on the list of possibilities. If you like more then one thing on the list, put your name by it but only once. I hope that makes sense?

    Of course moderators and admins are also welcome to vote too.
    •  
      CommentAuthorbradm81
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    I'm changing my vote to go with the crowdbakie

    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul
    janpd24
    NickyD
    wfiedler

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24
    conartistdesign
    NOWdesign
    aaroncampbell
    icyone
    DENiAL
    Urgenus
    yugnats
    bradm81

    14. Retro design
    • CommentAuthorDeanStev
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008 edited by DeanStev on the 23rd April 2008 at 14:20:38 EDT
     
    How come Janpd24 voted twthrice?

    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81

    14. Retro design
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    @DeanStev: You can vote for more then one choice on the list... but I guess to keep things moving, you can only choose two things from the list? How does that sound?
    •  
      CommentAuthorJeremyD
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    In that case, I've added my name to another.

    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD

    14. Retro design
    • CommentAuthorrefueled
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008 edited by refueled on the 23rd April 2008 at 15:00:58 EDT
     
    My original vote was for the aviation theme, but since no one has voted for it yet, I'll add my name to #13.

    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD,
    refueled

    14. Retro design
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    Just keeping the thread on top
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    @pete: I've made this thread sticky, so it will now be on top.
    •  
      CommentAuthorgnome
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24
    Gnome

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD,
    refueled

    14. Retro design
    Gnome
    •  
      CommentAuthorkirby145
    • CommentTimeApr 23rd 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe
    kirby145

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24
    Gnome

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD,
    refueled

    14. Retro design
    Gnome
    •  
      CommentAuthorjanpd24
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    Hey, I need to remove my name from one of the votes! Who's keeping count? Just to update (only removed my name, didn't add anything ;) ):

    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe
    kirby145

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24
    Gnome

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD,
    refueled

    14. Retro design
    Gnome
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    Keep the votes coming...

    Posted By: janpd24Who's keeping count?


    I am/ anyone can... the final numbers can really only be counted with the final post of this thread, that is, the current count is the current post. Others may change their mind towards the end so it's no use counting now. In any case this thread makes it a good record for accountability.

    Should we allow votes to change? I can't see why not... I'll add it to the top post.

    Pete
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    Please note...

    You may change your vote/s at anytime, just make sure you make a NEW post to reflect your change (DON'T JUST UPDATE YOUR OLD POST) - the final count will be the what the final post reads.
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    Why should people change votes? Once they vote, that should be it. When you vote for Presidents and other things, you can't change your vote. Once in, that's it. People need to think about the vote, make a vote and stick to it.
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    Being able to change votes will actually make the vote result more 'accurate'. Let me explain how.

    It is becoming clear the vote is a 2 horse race. As the vote goes on it will be clear those who have not voted for these 2 horses will have effectively wasted a vote or more or less had no 'effective' input.

    By allowing everyone to change their minds it effectively gives us the vote a built in system of second and third and fourth and [add infinitem] preferences. It is effectively the same as (much better than actually) allowing 2 votes. Ideally the most accurate result is one where there is no wasted votes, and this ensures that (should the voters wish to exercise that choice).

    This is what we don't want to see...

    theme 1. 150 votes
    theme 2. 155 votes
    theme 3. 10 votes

    the winner is theme 2. but all those who voted for theme 3 have wasted their votes unless they can change their votes. They could potentially all votes for theme 1. and therefore theme 1 would be the winner (and the more accurate winner).

    Having said that we shouldn't be allowed 2 votes. Just the option to change votes.

    The Presidential elections are not like this only because it would be impossible for the vote to handle updating all the country's vote over two weeks like this - but it would be a whole heap more accurate - they have to draw the line somewhere. We have the luxury of a small voter population and easy means to update the voters choice and so we should do so for a more truer result.

    No one will be able to say they didn't have a 'meaningful' say in which theme should win.

    Elections should be held this way too.
    • CommentAuthorXSQueen
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev
    XSQueen

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe
    kirby145

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24
    Gnome

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD,
    refueled

    14. Retro design
    Gnome

    15. MOOD theme (i.e. happy/sad/grunge/angry/gothic/romantic/sneaky/etc) to be picked by Sean
    XSQueen
    •  
      CommentAuthorperthmetro
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    To make this vote the fairest possible I think there should be only one vote and have that one vote changable (see my previous post)... having two votes corrupts the fairness of the vote changing and therefore makes it less fair/accurate overall.
    •  
      CommentAuthorLobsterMan
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    I'll add my vote to a travel destination.
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008 edited by Sean on the 24th April 2008 at 14:15:16 EDT
     
    @pete: Your theory is an interesting one but I still don't agree.

    If it ended up like you said:

    theme 1. 150 votes, theme 2. 155 votes, theme 3. 10 votes

    Which would show theme 2 won, that's great. The voting system works.

    In your example the people who voted for #3 are the lowest vote. If everyone had the chance to change a vote to go with the majority, why even have a vote in the first place?

    You win some, you lose some. That's how voting works.
  45.  
    I think what he's saying is:
    Imagine this situation:
    150 people prefer #1
    155 people prefer #2
    10 people (who vote first, not knowing how things will end up) prefer #3. However, of those 10, 8 feel very strongly that #3 is the best option and dislike #2 passionately. Near the end, seeing that their favorite option has no way to win, they can adjust their vote to make sure that the one they DON'T want loses.

    I'm not saying this is the best option, just that it does allow certain strategic advantages to the voters beyond just voting with the masses.
    •  
      CommentAuthorSean
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    I still stand by what I said. A vote is a vote. If people can change or alter a vote on a whim, what's the point in even voting.
  47.  
    Sounds fair to me.
    •  
      CommentAuthorgreg
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    1. a colour theme (to be picked by Sean)
    perthmetro,
    kirby145,
    ramblingsoul,
    janpd24,
    NickyD,
    wfiedler,
    DeanStev,
    XSQueen,
    greg

    2. Aviation theme

    3. 'No theme' theme

    4. Bakie Cookie theme
    JeremyD

    5. Old Age Home (Charity)

    6. News Paper (Not Blog)
    bluecafe
    kirby145

    7. Mac Showroom website

    8. Grocery Shop

    9. Vineyard Website

    10. Travel destination
    Janpd24
    Gnome

    11. non-blog theme

    12. iPhone, mobile browser, small resolution theme

    13. "OD Garden" (A CSS Zen Garden type contest that someone had mentioned in the earlier thread)
    Janpd24,
    conartistdesign,
    NOWdesign,
    aaroncampbell,
    icyone,
    DENiAL,
    Urgenus,
    yugnats,
    bradm81,
    JeremyD,
    refueled

    14. Retro design
    Gnome

    15. MOOD theme (i.e. happy/sad/grunge/angry/gothic/romantic/sneaky/etc) to be picked by Sean
    XSQueen

    16. image-free
    greg
    •  
      CommentAuthorgnome
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    Why don't we have a vote-off between the two obvious majorities? That prevents the problem outlined above, even if it is more rigourous and time consuming.
    •  
      CommentAuthorgreg
    • CommentTimeApr 24th 2008
     
    XSQueen and myself just added additional ideas, and everyone who has already voted doesn't get to choose any of the ideas added after their vote - we needed to compile and agree on a list of ideas BEFORE voting. and i still think this voting system sucks :p

1 to 50 of 81

  1. <
  2. 1
  3. 2
  4. >